Christian Cyclopedia

About the Cyclopedia

Atonement, Theories of.

Among the theories of atonement, which objectors to the Scriptural doctrine of the vicarious atonement of Christ offer as substitutes, are 1. The Accident Theory: Christ's death was an accident, as unforeseen and unexpected as that of any other victim of man's hatred (held by Modernists; see Modernism); 2. The Martyr Theory: Christ gave up His life for a principle of truth that was opposed to the spirit of His day (held by Modernists; see Modernism); 3. The Declaratory Theory: Christ died to show men how greatly God loves them (see also Ritschl, Albrecht Benjamin); 4. The Moral-Example Theory (Moral-Influence Theory; Moral-Power View of the Atonement): Christ died to influence mankind toward moral improvement (held by Socinians [see Socinianism and H. Bushnell*); 5. The Governmental Theory: God made Christ an example of suffering to exhibit to erring man that sin is displeasing to Him; or: God's govt. of the world made it necessary for Him to evince His wrath against sin in Christ (held by H. Grotius* and New* Eng. Theol.); 6. The Guaranty Theory: Reconciliation is based not on Christ's expiation of sin, but on His guaranty to win followers and thus conquer human sinfulness (held by F. D. E. Schleiermacher,* O. Kirn,* and J. C. K. v. Hofmann*); 7. The Classic or Dramatic Theory: the atonement as divine conflict and victory (held by G. E. H. Aulén*). All these and other man-made theories of atonement deny Christ's vicarious satisfaction and are based on the same leading thought: salvation by works, or salvation through personal sanctification, stimulated by Christ's death. See also Christus Crucifixus; Double Reference Theory of the Atonement; Lund, Theology of; Recapitulation; Sweden, Lutheranism in, 6. JTM

R. S. Franks, A History of the Doctrine of the Work of Christ in Its Ecclesiastical Development, 2 vols. (London, 1918) and The Atonement (London, 1934); G. Aulén, Christus Victor, tr. A. G. Hebert (London, 1931); P. A. W. H. Althaus, Die Theologie Martin Luthers (Gütersloh, 1962), pp. 191–195, 2d ed. (Gütersloh, 1963) tr. R. C. Schultz, The Theology of Martin Luther (Philadelphia, 1966), pp. 218–223.

Edited by: Erwin L. Lueker, Luther Poellot, Paul Jackson
©Concordia Publishing House, 2000, All rights Reserved. Reproduced with Permission

Internet Version Produced by
The Lutheran Church--Missouri Synod

Original Editions ©Copyright 1954, 1975, 2000
Concordia Publishing House
All rights reserved.

Content Reproduced with Permission

Stay Connected! Join the LCMS Network:

Contact Us Online
(Staff Switchboard)
(Church Info Center)
1333 S Kirkwood Rd
Saint Louis, MO 63122-7226 | Directions


Featured Publication

The Lutheran Witness

LCMS Communications

Interpreting the contemporary world from a Lutheran Christian perspective.
Visit TLW Online